Bat, Pad, or Benefit of the Doubt? Why the Third Umpire Got Shubman Gill’s LBW Review Wrong
When you stand in the middle for sixteen years, you see all kinds of LBW appeals. From my very first ECB-recognised match at Alexandra Park back in May 2010 in the Middlesex Championship, right up to officiating in the Cherwell League and the Home Counties Women’s Premier League this season, one thing has never changed: the bat-and-pad LBW is the biggest headache for any umpire.
Watching Day 3 of the first Test between New Zealand and India, that exact headache played out in front of the whole world. In the 107th over, Nathan Smith bowled a lovely nip-backer on a good length to Shubman Gill. The ball was swinging in nicely. Gill came forward to defend, the ball struck the pad, New Zealand went up in a huge appeal, and on-field umpire Richard Illingworth raised his finger.
What happened next is why we are still talking about it.
The Tell-Tale Signs on the Field
As an umpire, you don’t just look at the ball; you also observe the batter’s body language. Normally, if a batter gets an inside edge onto the pad, their hand goes up for a review in a split second. They feel that vibration through the handle straight away.
Here, Gill didn’t seem to feel anything at all. He had a long chat with Rishabh Pant at the other end and only called for the review with just three seconds left on the timer. Even the New Zealand players were completely convinced there was a gap between bat and pad—one of them even shouted out to the third umpire, Kumar Dharmasena, asking if he could see the gap, to which Pant cheekily replied that Kumar isn’t blind.
Where the Third Umpire Went Wrong
When the decision went upstairs, everyone waited for Sonic (UltraEdge). A spike did appear on the screen, and the third umpire concluded that the ball was next to the bat on the left-hand side, telling Richard Illingworth, “I got a spike. Richard, I got bat involved.” With that, the on-field OUT decision was overturned, and naturally, the crowd started booing while Nathan Smith, Rachin Ravindra, and Daryl Mitchell went straight to Illingworth for an explanation.
Now, looking at this purely from an umpire’s perspective, I have to disagree with the third umpire here.
Yes, at first glance, the spike seems to be from the bat. But if you look closely at the very next frame, the ball is hitting the pad at the exact same time. Crucially, there was no second conclusive spike to separate bat from pad. On top of that, the ball was swinging in. When a ball swings in late and hits the front pad right next to the inside edge, the sound waves and the frames can easily overlap.
In the DRS protocol, the golden rule is simple: to overturn an on-field decision, you must have conclusive evidence.
Here, the on-field call was OUT. Was there 100% conclusive proof that the ball hit the bat before the pad? In my view, no. When there is doubt like this—one single spike with bat and pad practically merging in the frame—the third umpire should not have rushed to overturn the on-field call. The right procedure would have been to stay with the on-field assessment of no conclusive bat, go to ball tracking, and if the ball was shown to be hitting the wickets, let the OUT decision stand.
Standing Without a Safety Net
Watching Nathan Smith and the Kiwis look so frustrated reminded me of so many Saturday afternoons I have spent in the Middlesex County Cricket League and Buckinghamshire county age-group matches. In club cricket, we don’t have Sonic, we don’t have slow-motion replays, and we don’t have a third umpire sitting in an air-conditioned box.
You get one look in real time. When a bowler swings one back in and you hear a single thud near the bat and pad, you have to trust your eyes, your ears, and your training. Sometimes, the batter walks off shaking his head; other times, the bowler is unhappy. That is simply the nature of this great game.
In international cricket, technology is supposed to remove the howlers—not overturn a strong on-field decision based on an inconclusive single spike. On this occasion, Richard Illingworth made a brave, solid call in the middle, and in my honest opinion, he deserved to have his decision backed up.
Written by Hari Nochiyil, panel umpire officiating across UK league and county age group cricket since 2009
Want to Test Your Own Umpiring Instincts?
Think you can spot the difference between an inside edge onto the pad, pitching outside leg, and a plumb LBW under pressure? Step into the middle and test your knowledge of MCC Law 36 in our interactive LBW Umpire Decision Quiz—or try chasing in one over challenge in the Super Over Batting Challenge – Cricket Blitz game.
